Writing The Lives and Deaths of Laurel and Hardy
Updated: Oct 22

Universal truths in The Lives and Deaths of Laurel and Hardy play
People are always interested in where the inspiration for a new play has come from, particularly one about iconic legends like Laurel and Hardy; after all, there are many experts on the lives of the two comic geniuses, and many commentaries on their films and partnership. With so much already said, is there anything left?
Biography is interesting. I am reminded of an anecdote I heard about the actor Geoffrey Rush who was working on a biographical film about Peter Sellers. According to the story, Rush turned to the director in the middle of filming a scene and said, "Yes, but what is this film about?". We never get to hear the director's response, but I think that the takeaway from the story is that Rush felt that simply achieving an accurate portrayal of a historical character is not enough, and that storytelling in any genre requires us to search for universal truths.
I agree with Rush. Our protagonists, in fiction or non-fiction, have the ability to move us when they touch us on a level we understand; when they demonstrate feelings we all feel too.
What is The Lives and Deaths of Laurel and Hardy about?
So, what is The Lives and Deaths of Laurel and Hardy about? It is about grief and friendship. With so much value in modern times seemingly placed on the experience of romantic love, platonic love (especially platonic love between men) seems to be less valued. In fact, I can think of few examples in art or literature where it appears as a main theme. The masterful novel Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck is one example - if you can think of more, or have recommendations, please do comment with them below.
However, losing a best friend can be a defining experience in a person's life, the grief made harder to bear by the sense that it is unseemly to be so upset by losing someone who was 'just a friend'.
Referencing The Music Box
It is also about the fight for artistic expression in a hostile, indifferent or absurd universe.
One example of this in The Lives and Deaths of Laurel and Hardy is in the conscious reference to Laurel and Hardy's 1932 film The Music Box. If you are a Laurel and Hardy fan (and I expect most people reading this will be!), you will know the premise of the film - Stan and Ollie are tasked with the job of delivering a piano to a home situated at the top of a steep flight of steps; after many failures and painful tribulations, they get the piano to the top of the steps, only to be told that there was a much easier way they could have come which avoided the steps altogether. Doomed to ultimate failure, Laurel, Hardy and the piano all end up in a garden pond.

In The Lives and Deaths, our protagonists - Stan and Ollie, of course - also have to transport a heavy box to a far-off and difficult-to-get-to destination; as in The Music Box, this is not easy. In the play, they solve the problem by taking the box apart to build steps out of it - and then find at what should be their moment of triumph on the top step that they have destroyed the very thing they needed! Of course, Stan cries and Ollie is angry.
I will leave it to the individual audience member to decide for themself what the box represents in The Lives and Deaths. However, I do contend that this kind of symbolism - the kind that is visual, that goes beyond words and belongs within metaphor and allegory - can be expressed best through stagecraft. The 'black box' of a theatre (along with the multi-disciplines of set, lighting, sound and costume design, music-scoring, choreography, written-word, and the unique talents of each individual actor) becomes a liminal space where things can become other things (a bedroom, a projections-room, a hospital, a staircase, a boat, a vast empty space), in the blinking of an eye.
Echoes of the Past
What makes The Music Box (which deservedly won an Oscar for Best Comedy Short) great, is that greatness of its subject matter - The Futility of Effort. Laurel and Hardy here invoke Greek Tragedy, as they become comic, Laurel-and-Hardy parodies of Sisyphus, doomed to the perpetual torment of pushing a boulder up a hill and never getting to the top.
Adding on to this, The Lives and Deaths evokes absurdist post-modernism by consciously reminding us of Beckett's Waiting For Godot ("Do we have time?" asks Stan. "Sure we have time" says Ollie. They sit and do nothing.) Things come full circle - many scholars believe that Beckett's bowler-hat-wearing characters Vladimir and Estragon were inspired by Stan Laurel and Oliver Hardy.

Both clowns and tragic heroes are timeless, as we know from the Greeks and from Shakespeare. Laurel and Hardy's heritage in theatre is covered in another blog post - but it is worth reminding ourselves here what we know to be universal; that clowns always tell the truth - although sometimes only in riddles.
In Godot, the protagonists use comedy for distraction. In The Lives and Deaths, Stan and Ollie fall back on comedy (the old lines from the old films, so familiar and safe) to avoid difficult subjects or emotions; but the comic devices they employ inadvertently become vehicles for expression. The painful truths evade attempts to dodge, indefinitely postponed or flee; rather, humour sharpens pain to exquisite
As Stan, in The Lives and Deaths of Laurel and Hardy, pretending to be Lucille, Ollie's wife (it is too painful for him to reveal reality as himself and he can only do it through the distance of parody), says of Ollie's fear of being laughed at with love of being laughed with: 'He is so graceful on that tightrope!'.
Balancing the tightrope is a perfect analogy for comedy and tragedy. They are without a doubt two sides same stage - one mis-step can topple you one way or the other.


Comments